ERT for Menopausal Women With History of Breast Cancer

Women with a history of breast cancer have been advised to avoid estrogen replacement therapy (ERT). A reassessment of this approach has been initiated by several authors and clinical reports to date have not supported this tenet. The only prospective randomized trial reported to date is that of Vassilopoulou-Sellin et al. The authors conducted a prospective clinical trial to assess the safety and efficacy of prolonged ERT in a group of menopausal women with localized (Stage I or II) breast carcinoma and a minimum disease-free interval of 2 years, if the estrogen receptor (ER) was negative, or 10 years if the ER status is unknown. For 5 years, the authors followed 77 trial participants and 222 other women with clinical and prognostic characteristics comparable to those of the trial participants. Overall, 56 women were on ERT, and 243 women were not on ERT. Patient and disease characteristics, such as tumor size, number of lymph nodes involved, ER status, menopausal status, and disease-free interval were comparable for women who were on ERT and women who were not on ERT. Two of the 56 women on ERT (3.6%) developed a contralateral, new breast carcinoma. In the group that was not on ERT, 33 of the 243 women (13.5%) developed new or recurrent breast carcinoma. There were no differences in the development of other carcinomas with respect to ERT. Thus, ERT did not compromise disease-free survival in select patients who were treated previously for localized breast carcinoma.

Additionally, observational studies reported by DiSaia, O’Meara, and Peters have supported this same conclusion. O’Meara assembled data from 2,755 women ages 35 to 74 years who were diagnosed with incident invasive breast cancer while they were enrolled in a large health maintenance organization from 1977 to 1994. Pharmacy data identified 174 users of hormone replacement therapy (HRT) after diagnosis. Each HRT user was matched to four randomly selected non-users of HRT with similar age, disease stage, and year of diagnosis. The rate of breast cancer recurrence was 17 per 1,000 person-years in women who used HRT after diagnosis and 30 per 1,000 person-years in non-users (adjusted relative risk for users, compared with non-users was equivalent to 0.50; 95% confidence interval was 0.30-0.85). Total mortality rates were 16 per 1,000 person-years in the HRT users and 30 per 1,000 person-years in the non-users.

DiSaia et al reported on 125 women who were breast cancer survivors with and without positive nodes, both ER positive and ER negative, who elected to take ERT or HRT. These patients were matched to 362 control patients from the same population base with the approximate ratio of four controls to one patient taking ERT or HRT. The risk of death was lower among the HRT survivors; odds ratio 0.28 (95% Cl 0.11-0.71). This analysis also did not suggest an adverse outcome with HRT use.

Peters interviewed 607 breast cancer survivors concerning ERT usage. Sixty-four patients indicated they had received some form of ERT after their breast cancer diagnosis. Eight patients were excluded because they had used only vaginal cream ERT. The remaining 56 received ERT as conjugated estrogens, an estradiol patch, or birth control pills. The median follow-up from diagnosis was 12.8 years and the median time on ERT since diagnosis was 6.4 years. One local recurrence and one contralateral breast cancer occurred during the follow-up period at 13.5 and 9.6 years respectively. There were no breast cancer deaths. The author also concluded that the use of ERT in a cohort of breast cancer survivors with tumors of generally good prognosis was not associated with increased breast cancer events compared with non-ERT users, even after a long follow-up period.

The question then remains as to whether all patients who have had breast cancer should be denied the benefits of estrogen replacement therapy. This is particularly relevant in the patient who has serious quality of life issues before her. At present, therapy with ERT/HRT is indicated in the management of quality of life issues, using lowest possible dose of hormone for shortest duration of time possible. Is it appropriate to deny a woman the option of taking replacement therapy for relief of her symptoms when there is no clinical evidence that it adversely affects outcome?

One Response to “ERT for Menopausal Women With History of Breast Cancer”

  1. […] main finding — that QOL was not significantly improved — was to be expected in this population. Symptomatic women were discouraged from participation, and vasomotor symptoms were reported by only 12% of the […]

Leave a Reply


  • italian restaurant viagra triangle
  • viagra aus indien bestellen
  • viagra acquisto italia
  • cialis plus fort viagra
  • viagra capsules in india
  • viagra price in kuwait
  • viagra cialis efeitos colaterais
  • over counter viagra turkey
  • generic viagra cheapest
  • why does cialis last longer than viagra
  • alternative viagra bayer
  • levitra viagra diferencia
  • what is the symbolism of the bathtub in cialis commercials
  • ajanta pharma - super kamagra
  • viagra effetto
  • viagra ou levitra
  • levitra penile rehabilitation
  • viagra blindness 2012
  • can you use rogaine and propecia together
  • levitra vs. viagra comparison
  • order viagra cialis online
  • propecia y el embarazo
  • se puede tomar viagra a los 30 años
  • cialis generika kaufen überweisung
  • has anyone used generic cialis
  • new cialis indication
  • comprar levitra paypal
  • viagra e giovani
  • como funciona o remedio cialis
  • cialis post radical prostatectomy
  • kamagra super p force
  • levitra generic cialis
  • farmacia. online cialis generico
  • compare viagra cialis levitra side effects
  • buy cialis miami
  • viagra e fertilit
  • cialis ordonnance
  • using cialis with viagra together
  • kamagra wie lange hält die wirkung
  • cialis 2.5mg 5 mg
  • viagra be recepto kaina
  • cual dosis levitra
  • mixing viagra alcohol dangerous
  • quanto tempo demora para agir o viagra
  • propecia hair loss
  • viagra soft tabs
  • compra viagra generico brasil
  • precio viagra andorra sin receta
  • propecia during steroid cycle
  • kamagra gel ook voor vrouwen
  • acquisto viagra roma
  • propecia 2 semaines
  • venden viagra farmacias similares
  • viagra spam virus
  • levitra cialis qual o melhor
  • viagra o farmaci simili
  • propecia discontinuing
  • can i take propecia every other day
  • propecia bad breath
  • comparacion entre viagra levitra y cialis
  • e quando o viagra nao funciona
  • levitra bucodispersable
  • cialis sans ordonnance france
  • kamagra malaga
  • other medical uses for viagra
  • cosa e' meglio viagra o cialis
  • l arginine and cialis together
  • 50 mg viagra price
  • kamagra soft tabs
  • what is better cialis or viagra
  • viagra super active ingredients
  • cialis de lilly
  • donde comprar viagra generico españa
  • cialis rezeptfrei online kaufen
  • viagra y fumar
  • cialis and bph
  • cialis south africa online
  • cual es mejor viagra levitra o cialis
  • nebivolol y viagra
  • viagra rite aid
  • puedo tomar cialis y priligy juntos
  • tesco pharmacy viagra cost
  • beneficios e riscos do viagra
  • säkert att köpa viagra på nätet
  • active ingredients viagra cialis
  • viagra drug classification
  • largest safe dose viagra
  • why doesn't propecia always work
  • 50 mg viagra reviews
  • comprar viagra original madrid
  • purple rockets cialis
  • el viagra sirve para eyaculacion precoz
  • can i buy viagra in australia
  • viagra 2 mal tag
  • se puede comprar viagra sin receta en andorra
  • buy generic cialis from canada
  • dejar tomar propecia
  • viagra oil women
  • tomar viagra a los 26 años
  • 5791653109
  • levitra informacion
  • viagra donde comprar buenos aires
  • levitra vision problems
  • levitra online with prescription
  • cialis user opinions
  • achat propecia generique
  • riscos do uso do viagra
  • buy viagra in nairobi
  • efectos de viagra en jovenes
  • levitra è pericoloso
  • diferencia cialis viagra levitra
  • viagra sin receta medica españa
  • best time take 36 hour cialis
  • duracion efecto levitra 20 mg
  • cialis 5mg effet secondaire
  • comparaison efficacite viagra cialis
  • diferencia entre viagra y viagra generico
  • comparison between levitra viagra
  • propecia trouble sleeping
  • mixing viagra with alcohol
  • acquistare cialis originale senza ricetta
  • can i take viagra with cialis
  • viagra plus priligy
  • ventajas de usar cialis
  • viagra cialis pour femme
  • blague viagra eau chaude
  • long does 1 viagra last
  • cialis therapeutic class
  • levitra cialis viagra side effects
  • viagra melon d'eau
  • maximum dosage viagra cialis
  • viagra alternatives over counter gnc
  • levitra bayer mexico
  • viagra skelbiu.lt
  • levitra cialis viagra comparaison
  • will viagra increase my libido
  • levitra 20mg vs viagra 100mg
  • gnc products like viagra
  • propecia y similares
  • teachers union fights viagra
  • buy cialis brand canada
  • kamagra oral jelly uk cheap
  • viagra y presion arterial alta
  • como usar viagra yahoo
  • illegal buy viagra online uk
  • cialis levitra viagra forum
  • difference between niagara viagra
  • cialis farmacia barcelona
  • is kamagra better than viagra
  • cialis comment le prendre
  • propecia plasma donation
  • donde comprar cialis peru
  • levitra 10 mg vendita
  • viagra levitra o cialis
  • is 5 mg levitra effective
  • differenze tra viagra e levitra
  • levitra how much should i take
  • gelato al viagra
  • viagra safe for young men
  • buy generic viagra cialis levitra
  • viagra picaturi pentru femei
  • viagra 3 day delivery
  • cialis buy europe
  • viagra in nepal
  • kann viagra deutschland kaufen
  • levitra brand
  • propecia 3. ay
  • buy blue kamagra
  • cialis or viagra better
  • natural herbal viagra reviews
  • cialis generico da 5 mg
  • propecia genital shrinkage
  • kamagra gel novi sad
  • viagra dostava zagreb
  • cialis generika forzest
  • cialis vs viagra espanol
  • shops sell kamagra
  • viagra original online
  • comprar cialis profesional
  • price cialis versus viagra
  • viagra available pbs
  • cialis ulcerative colitis
  • viagra gençlere zararlı mı
  • kamagra green tabletta
  • propecia 3. ay
  • propecia price with prescription
  • generic viagra uk online
  • viagra ralenti l ejaculation
  • tomar cialis e viagra juntos
  • levitra usa 20 mg . 30 comprimidos
  • levitra effets
  • viagra triangle chicago bars
  • kamagra super active
  • what age do men need viagra
  • propecia infertilit
  • brand viagra online prescription
  • viagra yahoo respuestas
  • levitra pill wiki
  • propecia available in pakistan
  • propecia 1 mg costco
  • pastillas levitra
  • quanto tempo dura o efeito do viagra 50mg
  • l-cia cialis
  • why bathtubs in cialis commercials
  • viagra levitra cialis precios
  • wikipedia kamagra oral jelly
  • kamagra gel indir
  • will viagra go off patent
  • kamagra oral gel buy
  • viagra v egypte
  • czy viagra szkodzi zdrowiu
  • propecia cost nz
  • viagra e fibrillazione atriale
  • cialis venda
  • buy viagra online india
  • coumadin levitra interactions
  • viagra cialis levitra wikipedia
  • occorre la ricetta medica per il cialis
  • cialis 5 mg presentacion
  • viagra contraindications
  • viagra 65 ans
  • price viagra lloyds pharmacy
  • tesco cut price viagra
  • cialis and viagra comparison
  • justin bieber propecia
  • venden cialis en farmacias del ahorro
  • cialis effetto